0424 916 895 admin@goengineering.net.au LinkedIn

Insights

Ore Reserve Estimation: Why Resources Aren't Reserves

17/11/2026By Cornelius Hattingh

By Cornelius Hattingh Declaring an Ore Reserve is not a matter of applying a confidence label to a resource. Ore reserve estimation is the outcome of technical work, judgement and sign-off that the JORC Code deliberately makes explicit. A resource a…

Ore Reserve Estimation: Why Resources Aren't Reserves

By Cornelius Hattingh

Declaring an Ore Reserve is not a matter of applying a confidence label to a resource. Ore reserve estimation is the outcome of technical work, judgement and sign-off that the JORC Code deliberately makes explicit.

A resource and a reserve are not the same number

It is tempting to treat a Measured or Indicated Mineral Resource as a reserve in waiting, as though confidence in the geology were the only thing standing between a resource estimate and a reserve statement. It is not. Under the JORC Code, an Ore Reserve is defined as the economically mineable part of a Measured and/or Indicated Mineral Resource, established only after Pre-Feasibility or Feasibility level studies have applied the Modifying Factors and demonstrated that extraction could reasonably be justified at the time of reporting. The reserve figure also carries dilution and expected mining losses that do not sit in the underlying resource. The Canadian CIM Definition Standards draw the same line: a Mineral Reserve requires at least a preliminary feasibility study before any part of a resource can be reclassified. Confusing the two, as AusIMM'sMine Managers’ Handbook(Monograph 26) notes investors often do, misreads what each term actually represents.

What a Mineral Resource is still missing

A Mineral Resource is, at its core, a geological inventory: a statement of tonnage and grade supported by sampling and interpretation, reported with a stated level of confidence. It tells a reader what might be there. It says nothing, on its own, about whether that material can be dug up and sold at a profit.

The JORC Code is explicit on this point. An Ore Reserve is defined as the economically mineable part of a Measured or Indicated Mineral Resource, and that status only applies once a Pre-Feasibility or Feasibility level study has applied what the Code calls the Modifying Factors: mining, processing, metallurgical, infrastructure, economic, marketing, legal, environmental, social and governmental considerations. Until that work is done, the Resource is an estimate of what exists, not a statement of what will be extracted.

This is why a company cannot simply relabel its Indicated and Measured Resources as Reserves. Each Modifying Factor has to be worked through and documented, and the result has to show that extraction can reasonably be justified at the time of reporting. Where any Modifying Factor is not known with the same confidence as the underlying geology, the Reserve classification is adjusted down to reflect that. The geological confidence sets a ceiling on the Reserve category; it does not set the floor.

The factors that can stall a resource on its way to a reserve

AusIMM'sStudy Processes Handbook(Monograph 35) groups the non-technical Modifying Factors that a study must work through as permitting, environmental, social and market considerations, and each can independently prevent a resource from converting to a reserve, regardless of how well the orebody is understood. Permitting status is the clearest example: if approval to mine is unlikely to be granted, no reserve can be estimated, no matter the confidence in tonnes and grade. Environmental factors, including waste characterisation and the status of approvals for tailings and waste storage, are frequently tied to the same permitting pathway and need to be read together. Social factors — agreements with stakeholders and progress toward a social licence to operate — sit in the same bracket, since approvals can stall if stakeholder matters remain unresolved. Market factors are different in character: they require an honest assessment of demand and supply trends, competitor behaviour, likely market windows and the basis for price and volume forecasts, and for industrial minerals, evidence that product specifications can actually be met.

As an illustration only, a deposit with excellent drilling density and a well-understood geological model could still fail to support a reserve declaration if a native title agreement is unresolved or if there is no credible market for the product at the assumed specification. The technical work and the non-technical Modifying Factors must both stand up.

The level of study the Code expects before a reserve is declared

JORC Clause 29 is explicit on this point: an Ore Reserve is defined by studies at Pre-Feasibility or Feasibility level that apply the Modifying Factors and demonstrate that, at the time of reporting, extraction could reasonably be justified. Deriving a reserve by simply factoring a resource figure, without an underlying mine design or mine plan, is not acceptable under the Code. The study must have produced a plan that is technically achievable and economically viable.

The JORC Code does not prescribe a rigid methodology for reaching that point, leaving the process to the Competent Person's judgement (see theMine Managers’ Handbook, Chapter 6, and AusIMM'sMineral Resource and Ore Reserve Estimation: The AusIMM Guide to Good Practice(Monograph 30), Table 1, Section 4 on study status). The Canadian CIM Definition Standards 2014 take a more prescriptive line: a Preliminary Feasibility Study must establish a preferred mining method or pit configuration and an effective processing route, supported by financial analysis built on reasonable assumptions across mining, processing, economic, marketing, legal, environmental, social and governmental considerations. Whichever code applies, the common thread is the same: a reserve rests on a study of sufficient maturity to support the decision it informs, not on a confidence label alone.

The Competent Person: sign-off with accountability, not a rubber stamp

A reserve estimate only becomes reportable once a Competent Person takes responsibility for it. The JORC Code sets a deliberately high bar: a Member or Fellow of the AusIMM or AIG with at least five years' experience relevant to the style of mineralisation and the activity being undertaken. Experience in resource estimation does not automatically qualify someone to sign off a reserve, which demands relevant experience in estimation, evaluation and economic extraction.

Reserve estimation is commonly a team effort spanning geology, mining, metallurgy, and other disciplines. Where responsibilities are clearly divided, good practice is for each contributing Competent Person to sign off their own area rather than have one person absorb the whole estimate. If a single Competent Person signs the documentation, that person carries responsibility for the entire report and must be satisfied that every contributor's work is sound before doing so.

ASX listing rules add a further layer for material mining projects. A market announcement must name the Competent Person, disclose their employer and professional membership, and any relationship that could present a conflict of interest. Critically, the announcement can only be released with the Competent Person's prior written consent to the form and context in which their work is presented. That consent requirement is what turns a technical opinion into an accountable public statement.

Why reserves are reviewed, not just reported once

An Ore Reserve is not a figure a company files once and leaves alone. The JORC Code requires Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves to be reviewed and publicly reported annually, with a nominated review date and an effective date shown against the estimate, and any material change discussed at the time it is published. Materiality cuts both ways: a company must promptly report a material change, whether the Reserve has grown, shrunk or shifted category.

For ASX-listed entities this is not just a JORC expectation. Chapter 5 of the Listing Rules requires a market announcement when an Ore Reserve estimate is reported for the first time or has materially changed, setting out a fair and balanced summary of the basis for the change. Continuous disclosure obligations can also be triggered independently of the annual cycle once the company holds all the information Chapter 5 requires it to disclose. The practical effect is that a Reserve carries an use-by assumption: the Modifying Factors that supported it must still hold, or the number needs revisiting.

What this means for your next study

If you are a study manager or mine planning consultant on the project, the practical test is simple: before reporting the reserve, can you point to the supporting study work, the Modifying Factors considered and the Competent Person responsible for each figure? If the answer is uncertain, the reserve statement is not ready—regardless of schedule pressure.

For directors signing off a market announcement, the same discipline applies in reverse: ask what study level underpins the number, who the Competent Person is, and whether anything material has changed since the last review.

Go Engineering's mining engineering consultants support study managers and boards through this process, from resource model review to Ore Reserve estimation and reporting. If your next study needs an independent check on the Modifying Factors or the Competent Person sign-off, talk to our Perth mining consultancy before the number goes public.

Sources

  • JORC Code 2012 — Clauses 29–32 (Ore Reserves, Probable and Proved definitions)
  • JORC Code 2012 — Clauses 9–17 (Competent Person, reporting terminology, material change and annual review)
  • AusIMM Monograph 35 — Study Processes Handbook — Chapter 4, Mining and Ore Reserves (Modifying Factors: permitting, environmental, social, market; Competent Persons)
  • AusIMM Monograph 30 — Mineral Resource and Ore Reserve Estimation — JORC Code 2012 Table 1, Section 4 (Estimation and Reporting of Ore Reserves); Competent Person guidelines
  • AusIMM Monograph 26 — Mine Managers' Handbook — Chapter 6.1, Capital Investment and Project Development (Resource-to-Reserve conversion, study level, concluding comments)
  • CIM Definition Standards 2014 — Mineral Reserve, Indicated and Measured Mineral Resource definitions (Pre-Feasibility Study requirement) — comparative context only
  • ASX Listing Rules Chapter 5 — Rule 5.9 (reporting of Ore Reserves for material mining projects)
  • ASX Guidance Note 31 — Section 10 (annual mineral resources and ore reserves statement; material change disclosure)
  • ASX Mining Reporting FAQs — Q10–13 (Competent Person sign-off, consent, conflict of interest disclosure)

Client and site details are kept confidential. We describe the nature of the work — commodities, methods and outcomes — rather than naming engagements.